This book has been on my list for a while, it’s one that
gets circulated a lot if you are interested in reading asexual characters. I
had not gotten around to it as it isn’t quite the genre I like the best (aka
historical fiction) but it was a fun, easy read to get through.
The book follows Felicity, a young girl in the 1700s who
desperately wants to become a physician despite only being rejected by medical
schools for being a woman. At the start of the book she is living with Callum,
a baker, in Scotland and she has to reject his offer of marriage. She heads to
London where her brother Monty and his boyfriend Percy live where she tries
again at a London medical school and is similarly rejected. However, she learns
that this legendary doctor, Dr. Platt, is about to set off on an expedition and
that he is getting married soon, so she wants to intercept him at the wedding
to an old friend of hers. However, Monty disagrees with this plan so she ends
up joining with a mysterious pirate of color named Sim to head there. Felicity
isn’t sure about Sim’s motives, it sounds like Sim wants to steal something,
but it’s too convenient for her to pass up.
They get there and Felicity has to try and make up with
Johanna, a childhood friend that she had a falling out with. Felicity remembers
it as Johanna demeaning her for not being interested in boys and parties, and
Johanna remembers it as Felicity looking down on her for being interested in
those things. They start to make up, and then Felicity catches Sim robbing
Johanna. Then Felicity realizes that Johanna has run away and she teams up with
Dr. Platt to find her in Zurich. Once there, Felicity overhears that Dr. Platt
wants to kidnap Felicity so she also sneaks away and runs into Johanna. Turns
out that she wants to get her mother’s things from a museum storage but they
won’t let her since she’s a woman. So Felicity goes to steal it and runs into
Sim trying to steal the same stuff.
They scuffle but then end up leaving together when Sim is
injured on a broken vial. Felicity treats her, and they learn that Johanna’s
mother was studying sea dragons, animals whose scales hold stimulating
properties. They make the trip to Africa, where Sim is from. There Felicity and
Johanna are separated and captured, but Monty shows up to save them from Dr.
Platt. They then all head to where the eggs are and fight the English, but a
sea dragon shows up to finish the deed for them and save her eggs. The book
ends with Sim and Felicity heading back to Africa so that Felicity can study
medicine there, and Johanna returns to England to claim Dr. Platt’s things.
Alright well first the ace representation. I thought
Felicity was well written in that she never uses the words “asexual” or
“aromantic” but it is very clear that this is what the author is going for.
Felicity doesn’t get the “spark” with other people or have any interest in
marriage or relationships. Potentially people would criticize this for going
too far in the other direction, where Felicity is a tomboy that looks down on
feminine women, but I think the subplot of her making up with Johanna and realizing
that it is ok to be more feminine is a really nice way to round out her
character.
There are times where the book is a little too obvious with
what it is doing. Of course Felicity and Johanna make up. Of course Sim ends up
not so different from Felicity after all. There was clearly a moment where
Felicity basically said “I’m not like other girls” and Sim said she probably
never looked for other girls like herself. But it is a young adult historical
fiction, so that’s ok. I don’t think criticisms calling female characters “too
modern” have much of a basis usually, there have always been women that care
about their rights and how other characters are treated and such. Felicity does
mention that she had to do some warming up to her brother being gay as well, so
it’s not like she had completely modern viewpoints either.
The sea dragons did feel pretty out of place to me. I don’t
think those are real creatures or anything, and to plop them into a pretty
straight historical setting felt inconsistent to me. The scales in particular,
I know that they need to like discover new things or something, but that felt
very much as though it was a Deus Ex Machina of medicine for Felicity and
Johanna to then study or whatever. And it isn’t totally needed, there’s plenty
of natural world in Africa that was ruined by colonialism to talk about.
Anyways, this was a quick and pretty fun read if not
completely my cup of tea. The characters are delightful and it’s easy to get
through. Just sometimes I think it could use a little more complicating.