Funnily enough I meant to read a different book called Only
Love Can Break Your Heart, but I ended up with this one and I read through
it anyways. It wasn’t a bad read, but it didn’t really stick out to me either.
A solid, middle-of-the-road work, which we always need some of those.
Our narrator is Richard, or Rocky for short. It starts with
him as a child with his mother, father that he only calls “the Old Man”, and a
troublemaker brother Paul. In particular there is one instance where Paul and
Rocky go to investigate an abandoned house across the street and Rocky sees
someone creep in and shoot Paul. That turns out to be the wealthy new owner of
the place. Paul recovers, and Rocky tells how he starts dating Leigh in high
school and they all hang out and listen to records together. Eventually, Paul’s
mom (from Old Man’s first marriage) dies and he goes to the funeral alone.
After that Paul disappears, taking Leigh with him. Leigh eventually reappears,
but no sign of Paul. Leigh gets engaged to the son of the family across the
street, and meanwhile Rocky starts a friendship with Patricia, the daughter of
the new owners across the street. Their relationship turns sexual. It comes
crashing down then when Leigh confides to Rocky that she had a hippie wedding
to Paul in a cult commune in New Mexico where the leader was also sleeping with
everyone, including molesting kids. Leigh came back and had an abortion
immediately. Rocky tells Patricia, word gets out, and the wedding ends in
disaster with Leigh having a mental crisis in the middle of it. To top it off,
Old Man has a stroke at the reception.
Leigh returns and starts reading to the elderly in town,
including Old Man. Her ex-fiancee leaves town for a while, along with Patricia.
Paul amazingly returns out of nowhere, and starts to help around the house now
that money is tight. Rocky manages to get kicked out of his rich school in an
attempt to help as well. Suddenly there’s a double murder across the street of
the couple in there. Everyone suspects Paul and Leigh. Meanwhile Rocky gets
back into acting and is cast as the lead in “Equus”, a play about a lovesick
stable boy and his horse god. Patricia accidentally incriminates herself to
Leigh and skips town to avoid being arrested, but those two are off the hook.
Patricia writes Rocky a letter saying her father was taking advantage of her,
and that’s why that happened. Rocky grows up, Old Man eventually dies, and the
book ends with Paul marrying Leigh and dying as well.
The genre of this is hard to pin down, some sort of Southern
gothic for sure, but there’s a small murder mystery as well. Definitely
coming-of-age too. It is a cool mix that really keeps you reading for sure.
Patricia frustrated me to no end, but having Paul and Leigh as constants really
helps. And gives you something to root for. I found it to be an easy read
overall.
The best part of the book is the play. When Rocky describes
opening night, the actors all get swept up in the energy of it and Rocky really
becomes this character. But even in the embodiment, he acknowledges that this
is really Paul he is playing. The outcast, maligned son fits him even better. I
loved the use of the play and the overlap of it with the characters and how the
play falls right at the climax where Paul is actually in jail and Patricia is
just being suspected. It is a great use of the story.
Overall, fun and easy read. I didn’t mean to pick it up but
I sure don’t regret it.