Another book that I think ended up on my reading list because I heard about it years ago and was intrigued, but I can’t totally remember. It was a really good read, the characters sucked me in and pulled me along their journey. I couldn’t wait to find out what happened next.
The story spans several decades but it starts in the sixties with one of a pair of twins that ran away from Mallard returning. The one returning is Desiree, and she brings a dark child with her. Mallard is odd in that it’s all Black people living there, but they have tried to make themselves as light as possible. It tells how Desiree ran away with her twin Stella, but then Stella ran off on her own (pretending to be white). Desiree married a darker man, had a kid, and had to run off with the child once that relationship became abusive. So she raises her child, Jude, in Mallard. Jump forward to Jude now heading to UCLA for college. She meets and falls in love with Reese, a trans man who also ran away from home. To save up money for his top surgery Jude starts working fancy parties, and at one of the parties gets a glimpse of Stella.
Fast forward a little more, Stella’s daughter Kennedy that Jude met at the party is starring in a show with one of their drag queen friends. Jude starts getting close to Kennedy, trying to learn about Stella. One night Stella comes to the show but doesn’t believe Jude when she says she’s Desiree’s daughter. Fast forward and jump to New York, Kennedy is trying to make it as an actress. Jude and Reese show up there as they had to move to get Reese’s surgery. Jude gives Kennedy a picture of their mothers as kids and they strike up a more friendly relationship. Stella learns about Jude, and finally visits Mallard as her mother suffers from Alzheimer’s. Kennedy eventually comes home and Stella comes clean to her daughter. Final jump, Jude is in medical school and learns her grandmother has died. She and Reese head back to Mallard for the funeral.
The book is largely about the different people we are and could be, and what happens when we cut off our past to be those people. Stella pretends to be white and has a whole new family. Reese runs off to be a man. Kennedy keeps trying to leave, unsuccessfully. Jude even has to go to LA to be herself. The foils of Stella and Reese, while not always directly compared, are interesting because it shows that this cutting off isn’t always a bad thing. Reese’s parents were abusive and he never heads back, although he still understands the importance of family and wants to be one with Jude. I thought it was a really interesting look at identity and race, and the lengths we are willing to go there.
I also just really loved Reese and all of their queer friends in LA. I wish there was more of that in the second half of the book. But it was so cool to see someone go through gender affirming care in the seventies and see that found family that they all have. Plus trans male representation is still so rare, it feels like something to treasure whenever it pops up.
The characters and the plot were all so compelling in this
book, I really loved going through it. It’s Bennett’s second novel, I’ll have
to try and find her first as well.