So I have once again ended up going back to the Redwall book
series, to read the ones that I never quite got around to in my childhood. This
one was an interesting one to start with, after not having read any of the
books in quite some time.
Rakkety Tam is
more or less a stand alone story of the Redwall world. As far as I can tell,
there aren’t any real concrete references to other books in the series, no
characters that bridge the gap to any previous ones. Having said that, the best
characters in this book are two completely new ones: the warrior squirrels Tam
and Doogey. Tam is from the Border while Doogey is a Highlander, and they both
wear kilts. You see where this is going? Jacques nails the accent in their
dialogue, and the fact that he dreamed up Scottish squirrels is pretty
hilarious.
The big bad this time is Gulo, a wolverine from the north
who is the first of his species in the series. His followers are ruthless, and
even eat their enemies (another first for the series). He is hunting for the
Walking Stone, which his brother took from him before departing into Mossflower
Wood.
As far as the plot goes, I think it was just a little too
much. The forces split several times, meaning that you have to keep track of
where the Redwallers, Long Patrol hares, and Guosim shrews are all at once. It
can become a little too much, with characters popping up seemingly out of
nowhere. Although it is good to have familiar faces such as the Long Patrol and
the Guosim around, consolidating them all would make it a little easier.
This story also relies on a lot of tropes, such as two
Redwall maids getting captured and then rescued by the heroes, riddles leading
to treasure, evildoers eventually going mad, and fighters becoming peaceful
once the fighting is over. With such creative characters, it would be nice to
see more creative plot lines as well. There are also several questions never
answered, such as what the significance of the Walking Stone is (and for that
matter why the dying wolverine told two Redwallers where it was). Honestly
since the motivation for the bad guys revolves around this, you would think
that it would have some meaning behind it.
So in the end, this is your typical Redwall story that
utilizes its tried and true tropes. There are inventive characters and ideas,
but they deserve a little better than the story surrounding them.
No comments:
Post a Comment