This is Mukherjee's second book, after "The Emperor of all Maladies" and it is just as prolific
as the first one. He describes this as a prequel to "Emperor" in the
sense that cancer is a genetic disease, so in describing cancer he is
describing how genes go wrong. While both books compliment each other, it is
also fine to read them separately. Honestly, this book is very similar to
"Emperor", nearly all the comments that I had for one apply to the
other.
When Mukherjee titled this "An Intimate History"
he meant it. Similar to "Emperor" there are many stories of patients
and their lives, as well as the researchers who sought to help them. In this
novel he also brings in his own family (similar to Carla from
"Emperor") to illustrate how genes have impacted him personally
through his family tree.
Mukherjee takes us through genetics and the idea of a gene
all the way from Mendel and Darwin to the present day. He does not shy away
from ethical dilemmas, and discusses the future and the wonders we will be able
to perform then. But he cautions against taking this power too far, after all
there are no "right" or "wrong" genes, just genes that are
better suited to different environments.
He also includes a brief discussion on genetic
investigations into sexuality and gender. While he presents a good overview of
the findings, he leans heavily towards the genes = gender idea (note that I did
not say genitals, I am referring to the Y chromosome here, which can be
suppressed and results in what is considered as female genitalia), which I am
hesitant about. Because there will always be one person who reads that and
disagrees and is alienated by the text. So there could be more nuance to that
discussion, but the science appears sound, just be cautious treading here.
One thing that I was surprised he didn't talk about was
GMOs, or genetically modified organisms. These are usually crops that have been
altered to express different genes. Such as rice that is more water-resistant,
or corn with added nutrients. There has been a lot of controversy over GMOs
lately, since people think that they are dangerous and only want
"natural" foods. Which is kind of funny really, as there is no such
thing as "natural" crops, we have been selecting genes for centuries
and breeding the best ones, creating GMOs is akin to taking that process and
speeding it up a little. There is nothing dangerous about it. Anyways, while
Mukherjee ignores GMOs, he does talk about stem cell research which is more
interesting anyways.
Another great book from Mukherjee that makes science
accessible to the general public. I would highly recommend it, whether you are
studying genetics or just mildly interested in the field.
No comments:
Post a Comment