Saturday, January 26, 2019

“Conan Doyle for the Defense” by Margalit Fox


As stated before, I am quite the Sherlock Holmes nut. So a book exploring how Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the writer behind Sherlock Holmes, once came to a man’s defense in court? Sign me up please.

Fox is telling a couple different stories here. First of all, there’s the crime. A rich, paranoid woman is killed in her home. Only a diamond brooch is found to be missing from her house. Who did it?

The man that the police arrest is Oscar Slater, a foreigner and a Jew. Determined to pin the crime on him, they arrest him and put him on trial. His voice is curiously absent from these proceedings, as he was advised not to testify due to his accent and the fact that everyone in Victorian times was racist. Who is he?

And then there’s Conan Doyle, already well-known for his Holmes stories and for coming to the aid of other underdogs. Oh and his obsession with spiritualism. That too. How did he get involved, and how did he eventually clear Slater’s name?

The entire story is told, from the general prejudices in Victorian times and societal norms, to the policeman who sacrificed his career after expressing doubts about the investigation, to the falling out between Conan Doyle and Slater after his release. Guesses are made as to who actually committed the murder, including Conan Doyle’s, but no one was ever convicted.

I found this book to be a delight. The subject matter is fascinating, as you rarely read about author’s lives since they are rarely this interesting, and Fox’s writing style is clear and easy to read. She keeps you turning pages up until the very end.

Honestly if you like mystery or history then this book is kind of a no-brainer. Those already into Holmes definitely are, and seeing a different side to his creator is incredible. Would highly recommend!

No comments:

Post a Comment