Friday, October 18, 2019

“The Truth About Robin Hood” by P. Valentine Harris


I picked up this book at the used bookstore in Detroit! It’s a quick read, just under a hundred pages. But boy is it a time. Harris here is trying to debunk the theories claiming that Robin Hood is nothing more than a myth or legend, primarily because the evidence suggesting this is lacking, and put forward his own theory that there was a real outlaw.

But first some background is in order. I tried to do some digging on this book, to see how reliable it is, and surprisingly I couldn’t find much. There isn’t a publication date in the book, but I managed to find some information off of the internet indicating that it was published around the 1950s-1970s. So it could be over 50 years old, I have no real way of knowing.

Related to that, I tried to find some reviews or critiques of the book to indicate whether or not Harris’s theories have been challenged or updated in any way. I could find literally nothing. I have no idea whether his ideas or accepted by the historian community or dismissed. And I am no expert on this subject, so take this all with a heavy grain of salt.

The book can be divided into roughly three parts. The first goes over the primary sources that we have about Robin Hood, as in the legends and ballads. The earliest known one is called the Lytell Geste and this is what Harris refers to again and again. Many changes have been made since there (primarily the addition of Maid Marian and Friar Tuck) so the original stories aren’t super familiar to contemporary audiences. Harris goes through them, as well as inferior ballads as well to sum up the evidence that we have.

The second part consists of Harris tearing down other historians’ theories of Robin Hood’s existence. This is honestly quite funny in places, as Harris seems to tire of coming up against the same incorrect ideas repeatedly. There are also points where he takes shots at their researching ability; I sense some animosity going on here… Regardless, the bulk of the book is dedicated to this section as Harris’s thesis is that you cannot prove that Robin Hood is a myth, therefore you cannot eliminate the possibility that he was real. Probably his most salient point towards this is that “Robin Hood,” or some variation thereof, was very common in medieval times and you would think that a legend would have a more unique name!

The third part is the shortest and consists of Harris’s own investigations in the legendary outlaw and his personal theory. Naturally, he thinks that he existed. Harris pins down several names mentioned in the Lytell Geste and evidence to suggest that the king at the time was King Edward II, known for associating with lower-class citizens and pardoning some. His personal idea is that Robin Hood was a small-time outlaw with a reputation for being an excellent archer and very kind to those whose paths he crosses. Over time, the story grew and changed, being associated with a variety of places and time periods. But originally there was an outlaw who started it all.

Knowing very little of the research, I thought this was a fascinating read. Obviously I wish it was a little longer; it is very short at only 100 pages. And I do wish that we heard more about Harris’s theory of the real-life Robin Hood, but since there is scant evidence and he focuses mainly on debunking others it is understandable that the focus is elsewhere. There are many things I would give to know how this information has been updated over the years, but until I find a book with a more recent publishing date, guess we will have to wait.

Wednesday, October 16, 2019

This Is Beautiful: Sherina Rodriguez Sharpe's Poetry

On a whim, I went to a Feminist Futures art launch party at a local gallery in Ann Arbor. There was some mediocre performance art, but by far my favorite part was a poet named Sherina Rodriguez Sharpe. She read this beautiful bell hooks excerpt, and some of her own poems.

My favorite part of her reading though was that after each part, she would ask "what in that bears repeating?" and people would speak up and suggest what parts were their favorite or what spoke to them. It was great because it forced us to process what we read and discuss it as a group. And I think it's a super important question to ask yourself repeatedly when you consume art.

What in that bears repeating?

Am I wasting my time here? What sections speak to me the most? What should be said over and over until everyone knows it? It's a surprisingly personal question, one that speaks to the audience and also to the artist. And it's definitely one that I want to think about more.

Oh and I'm definitely going to look up all of her poems, they were gorgeous, join me on that adventure if you'd like.

Saturday, October 12, 2019

Detroit


So about an hour’s drive away from Ann Arbor is Detroit! It definitely has more of a city feel, and has more going on than Ann Arbor. I originally went up for the Detroit Jazz Festival, and would highly recommend that. It’s the largest FREE jazz fest in the US! But since it probably isn’t summer when you’re reading this, here’s other things to do.

In terms of museums, Detroit has a whole bunch of good ones. There’s the Detroit Institute of Arts which has a huge collection in a gorgeous building. The exhibits span ancient cultures all the way up to the present day. There is also a wonderful collection of African-American art that showcases Detroit natives. Then there’s the Detroit Historical Society, which gives you the history of the town. And the Motown Museum, a must visit for any music fans!

There were a couple of really nice stores that I stopped by on my visit. For music lovers, Third Man Records is an incredible record store with a ton of music paraphernalia as well. You can even tour their pressing facilities! But what really drew me was that they have a small record booth where you can record 2.5 minutes of yourself singing, talking, or playing, and it’ll spit out a record for you! So I am now the proud owner of a record of me playing “Smash Mouth” on a kazoo. Another great store is John K. King Used and Rare Books. It’s the biggest bookstore in Michigan! The store is in a warehouse with four floors of books stacked from floor to ceiling. It’s so big that the employees hand out maps at the entrance! I found several books that I’d been looking for in there. Lovely place.

Obviously there is much more to Detroit, but those were the highlights of my visit. Detroit tends to get a bad rep after the housing crisis/economy crash, but it certainly is making a comeback now. And as a prominent music city, there is plenty to do for any music lovers! Well worth a visit or even two.

Wednesday, October 9, 2019

This Is Beautiful: Love Fame Tragedy

Okay so I think everyone knows that I'm a big fan of the band The Wombats. Recently one of the members, Murph, split off to do a solo project with a whole bunch of collaborations with people like Bastille and the like. The group is called "Love Fame Tragedy" and their first EP just dropped, "I Don't Want to Play the Victim, But I'm Really Good At It." It is excellent!

There are only a couple songs on it, but it really meshes the sense of fun that all of The Wombats' songs have with a little more seriousness and less playfulness. The result is a very polished body of work that still will force you to have a good time. That's not to say that I think this is better than The Wombats, I really like their messy feel, but it's different and similar and still soooo good.

Check it out on Spotify here!

Friday, October 4, 2019

Ann Arbor


So I have now been living in Ann Arbor for a couple of weeks, and it is such a cute little town to be in! There isn’t a ton of things going on, but there are a couple of highlights. And it’s just nice being in a small town while I work on my PhD, so I don’t mind it.

First of all, the museums. There are a number of museums associated with the University such as the museum of art, archeology, and natural history. All of them are rather small, only takes an hour or so to go through them, but they all have some pretty cool things in their collection. I really liked the art museum in particular since there’s a Monet and a special exhibit right now on Schiele.

Besides that, there are a bunch of outdoors-y nature things to do. I walked up to the Leslie Nature Center and really got a kick out of the raptor enclosures up there. There’s a bunch of owls, and even a bald eagle! Then there’s the Huron River, you can catch people tubing and kayaking down the river at any point when the weather is nice. Finally, there’s the Arboretum. In the spring there are fields of peonies but it’s a lovely stroll at any point of the year.

And that’s the bulk of things to do in Ann Arbor! Like I said, not much, but it’s all very cute and very accessible to anyone, nothing I mentioned actually has an entrance fee. I’m looking forward to getting to know this city more!

Wednesday, October 2, 2019

This Is Beautiful: Departmental Retreats

This past weekend I was off on a departmental retreat with my fellow grad students and professors. I thought it was going to be long, exhausting, and fundamentally awkward since it's a bunch of PhDs all in close proximity. And it was all of that, but it was also so much fun as well!

It was great spending some time just getting to know everyone else in the department. As a new student, I don't know too many of them, but at the same time there isn't exactly an abundance of social events to get to know each other outside of the classroom or lab. So it was great to just take a weekend to hang out with them.

I had a great time, a better time than I expected actually, and I hope that this energy carries me though the next couple of days while all of the sleep deprivation catches up with me haha.

Sunday, September 29, 2019

Vienna


Now the only other city I visited for the first time this summer was Vienna. I basically already knew that I’d really like Vienna since it’s THE city for music history. So many famous composers and musicians have lived in Vienna, it was quite a treat to see the sites in person.

Number one best place in the city might be the enormous food market, Naschmarkt. It’s enormous, and serves everything from Viennese food to Asian food. The slight difference in culture was really evident here, as I couldn’t hear many people speaking English. Nearby is St. Stephen’s Cathedral, a beautiful piece of Gothic architecture. The inside is gorgeous as well, it’s a quick visit but well worth it. Also nearby is the Vienna State Opera House. You need to be part of a tour to look around inside, but the guided tours are in a number of different languages and take you through several break rooms, the audience, orchestra pit, and the stage while discussing the history of the opera. Plenty of art is dedicated to the different composers, particularly Mahler since he was a very important director of the Vienna Opera. I didn’t know this before, but the Opera House was heavily bombed during WWII so a number of rooms have had to be reconstructed. Besides July and August there are operas being performed every day, and standing room tickets are only a couple of euros. I’ll have to come back and see that!

Unfortunately the only museum that I had time to visit was the Belvedere. The Belvedere used to be a wealthy art collector’s house, now it shows Austrian paintings, particularly by Klimt, Schiele, and Kokoschka. Klimt’s “The Kiss” is there and is probably it’s most famous painting. I quite enjoyed the Belvedere, possibly because I wasn’t as familiar with Viennese paintings beforehand, and was surprised that there were a couple of Rodin sculptures as well! Having said that, the collection is rather small and they seem to constantly be loaning paintings out, so check before you grab tickets!

My stay in Vienna ended by seeing a performance by the Vienna Mozart Orchestra. This is an orchestra that tries to recreate what music was in Mozart’s time by dressing in period costumes and showing a selection of pieces from different symphonies or operas instead of a full work. We purchased standing room tickets, which is about all that I would pay for it. The orchestra was fine, but nothing special. I’m sure that we could find much better in Vienna if we had planned it out a little better haha!

Vienna was a beautiful city with so much art and culture within it. I really wish that I could have spent more time there, but the taste I had was so much fun that I’m certain I’ll eventually come back for more.